“I know I’ll do very well,” Balfe bragged about herself before the test got underway. She then asked Heughan tauntingly, “How well will you do, Sam?” His deadpan response: “Yeah, I’m already setting myself up for the fall here.” Loads of Balfe and Heughan’s charming chemistry is on display throughout the 10-minute clip, but more importantly, who won the challenge? Keep reading to find out all the questions Balfe and Heughan answered about one another and who came out victorious!

What app does Sam Heughan use the most?

First up, Heughan asked Balfe, “What app do I use the most on my phone?” Balfe replied with a telling giggle, “Does it begin with an R?” Hmm… “r” guess is that she was hinting at the celebrity dating app Raya, even though recent reports have suggested that Heughan is currently happily dating model Monika Clarke. In any case, she ultimately settled on Instagram as her final answer, and she was right!

What kind of cocktail would Caitriona Balfe be?

Moving on from more real-world topics, Balfe then asked Heughan, “If I was a cocktail, what kind of cocktail would I be?” Heughan said, “I would describe you as an Irish coffee. However, I think you would describe yourself as a gin martini.” Wrong and wrong! Balfe said she’s be a “spicy margarita” and even drew a sketch of one!

What qualities does Sam Heughan look for in a romantic partner?

Balfe giggled again at this question, while Heughan decided to let her tell him what the correct answer would be. Her list included “must like fitness” (to which Heughan said, “That’s true”). Balfe then added “kind” and “adventurous” before Heughan chimed in with “great at conversation.” Hilariously, Balfe’s final quality she added to the list was “borderline alco.” What is Caitriona Balfe’s favorite episode of Outlander? This one proved to be a stumper for both stars. Heughan finally blulrted out “Faith,” which Balfe did admit would be her “favorite out of Season 2,” but she put down the very first Outlander ep as her fave.

What is Caitriona Balfe’s favorite episode of Outlander?

The very first one, of course (although Heughan guessed the Season 2 episode titled “Faith”).

What is Sam Heughan’s favorite item of clothing?

Balfe seemed not to know how to answer this one at first, but then she guessed, “Because you have seven million of them… leather jacket.” Ding ding ding! That’s exactly what Heughan wrote down.

How many languages does Caitriona Balfe speak?

Three was the right answer, and that’s exactly what Heughan guessed, although both he and Balfe agreed that it’s more like “three-ish” and that it depends on whether or not Balfe is sober (lol). For extra credit, Heughan then listed those three languages as “English, Gaelic and French.”

What’s Sam Heughan’s favorite drink?

Not a stumper at all! Balfe simply answered “whisky” with a nod and Heughan quickly confirmed her response with a “come on!” (As any Heughligan knows, tktk.)

What is Caitriona Balfe’s idea of a perfect date?

“A good meal, a couple drinks, cinema… probably a nap at some point,” was Heughan’s answer. He got full credit for that guess; what Balfe wrote down was “fancy dinner, good wine.”

What is Sam Heughan’s favorite thing to cook or bake?

“You’re not gonna get it,” Heughan sadly told Balfe as he wrote down his answer. After thinking it over for a moment, Balfe guessed, “Would you soak some porridge or something?” Shockingly, yes he would! “Yesss!” Heughan exclaimed as he turned around his card to show the answer he’d written down: Porridge! Balfe then dissed him by suggesting that making porridge is not really cooking.

What is the strangest place where Caitriona Balfe has ever been recognized?

After some hemming and hawing, Heughan answered, “Like a bathroom or something?” Yes, and as Balfe added, “And I was very naked. Two old ladies came over to me.” She added that it took place in the changing room at the Blue Lagoon, which Heughan then noted is a spa in Iceland.

What is Sam Heughan’s favorite professional sport?

“To watch? it’s probably either MMA [mixed martial arts] or rock climbing?” Balfe guessed before adding, “Or rugby?” Heughan let out a sigh of relief as he revealed that she got it right on her third guess. A fight about Ireland vs. Scotland in the sport of rugby ensued.

What is Caitriona Balfe’s favorite way to relax?

“It could be a bath, but I think it’s gonna be a book,” said Heughan, which lined up pretty perfectly with Balfe’s written-down response: “Lying on the sofa reading.”

Who does Sam Heughan turn to for advice?

He turns to his co-star Balfe, duh! At this point, the two congratulated themselves on how well they were faring in the game.

What is Caitriona Balfe’s go-to karaoke song?

As Balfe scribbled down her answer, she told Heughan he could guess a singer rather than a song. “Is it Blondie?” he guessed. And it was! (Although Blondie is technically a band fronted by Debbie Harry and not a person, but whatevs!)

What is Sam Heughan’s favorite book?

The duo’s winning streak came to an end here, after Balfe failed to guess either Outlander (duh again!) or, as Heughan put it, “one of my many New York Times bestselling books.”

What is Caitriona Balfe’s favorite movie?

Balfe did not take a cue from Heughan’s answer above by naming her own highly acclaimed 2021 film, Belfast. And it seems Heughan knew she wouldn’t pull a move like that, even as he struggled to remember the correct answer. “Oh! Um…. Vietnam. Uh, ‘Private Pyle, what is your major malfunction?!’” he began, quoting the movie even as he couldn’t remember its name. “What’s it called, though?” Balfe then turned around her card to reveal Full Metal Jacket, for which Heughan received full credit.

What was Sam Heughan’s worst experience on the set of Outlander?

Both of them agreed that there were several right answers to choose from here. Heughan, in fact, didn’t settle on a single episode per se, but just wrote, “end of Season 1.”

If Caitriona Balfe was a Real Housewife, what city would she be in?

“New Joisey” was Heughan’s guess, which was close, but no cigar! “New York” was Balfe’s answer, and she refused Heughan’s suggestion that his answer was “close enough.” Who won the game in the end? Balfe, who said humbly, “We’ve all seen that we both know each other very well but I know I’m better.” Next, Outlander Season 7 Has Started Filming! Plus, Everything Else We Know About the Show’s Future 

Who Knows The Other Better  Outlander s Caitriona Balfe or Sam Heughan  - 50